i'd choose a new bag probably 9 out of 10 times. i'm a purse hoarder. i don't know what it is, but i just don't have any self-control when it comes to a new bag. however, i also have a thing for gold. and wedges. so, those shoes might win. it's tough to say.
i feel like i should also mention that i'm not actually planning on purchasing either of these items, i'm just curious as to what you would pick! but, let's be honest, i would gladly take either of them.